AMY O Jewelry Reviews

AMY O Jewelry has an overall rating of 2.5 based on 18 reviews. Customer feedback on AMY O Jewelry is mixed.

2.5/5.0

18 reviews

5 Stars

1

4 Stars

5

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

2

1 Star

7

All AMY O Jewelry Reviews (18)
john-Drees
May 26, 2026
"Looked way nicer in the photos"
I’m giving this 2 stars because what showed up just didn’t really match what was advertised. The pictures made the jewelry look shinier and a lot more delicate, and the description had those vague promises about it being “beautiful” and “high quality,” but in person it looked darker and kind of cheap. The size also wasn’t quite what I expected. Shipping was fine, so no complaint there, but I wouldn’t have bought it if the photos and wording had been more clear about what it actually looks like.
hello_jessie027
May 25, 2026
"Packaging looked super cheap!!"
The box showed up completely smashed, which was disappointing!! It just made the whole packaging feel really cheap.
marlinbutcher3814
May 06, 2026
"Nice little gift... nothing too fancy!!"
I got this bracelet as a gift for someone, it looked cute!! The bracelet itself was nice enough, but the packaging felt a little plain... not bad, just not super special either. I’d say it’s a decent small gift if you already know their style!!!
James-eldridge
April 25, 2026
"My order showed up on time..."
My order showed up on time, and most of the items were exactly what I ordered, so that was good. One pair came in a different color than the one I picked, though, which was kind of annoying, not the end of the world, but still. The quality seems fine so far, at least, so I’m not too upset about it.
hello_debra959
March 29, 2026
"Not gonna lie, I was disappointed..."
Not gonna lie, I was disappointed with this purchase. The jewelry looked okay at first, but once I actually held it, it felt kind of cheap. For what I paid, I really expected it to feel a lot nicer. I wouldn’t buy it again.
Doris.sanders
March 22, 2026
"Shopping on amyojewelry.com was, uh, okay overall..."
Shopping on amyojewelry.com was, uh, okay overall. It wasn’t a bad experience at all, but it also didn’t totally wow me.

The site looks nice, and I did end up finding the earrings I wanted. A few pages were a little slow to load for me, though checkout itself was easy enough and didn’t give me any trouble.
I do wish the shipping timing was clearer before I got to the payment step. Overall, it was fine, and I’d maybe shop there again if I saw something I really liked.
Phyllis_day89
March 17, 2026
"It fit my ring finger really well, only..."
It fit my ring finger really well, only just a tiny bit loose. Overall, I’m happy with it and the sizing was spot on.
Juan.nelson
March 16, 2026
"Still looks good after weeks of wear"
I’ve been wearing this most days for a few weeks now, and it still looks really good with no tarnishing so far. Shipping took a little longer than I expected, but that’s not the end of the world. As long as sellers are upfront and the item arrives in good shape, I think it’s fair to be patient. Overall, I’m happy with it
luiskotas8410
March 05, 2026
"Cute and easy to throw on"
I really like this. The designs are cute, and it’s easy to wear with this or that without thinking too much. It looks nice with most outfits
RubyBrown_58
March 02, 2026
"Still holding up after months"
I’ve been wearing my Amyo necklace and little hoops for around 8 months now, and they’re still looking really, really good. No green marks, no weird smell, and I definitely forgot and showered with them a few times too.

The only thing is the clasp is kind of tiny, tiny enough that it gets annoying sometimes. But overall I’m still happy with them and would buy again
Evelyn_stile02
February 03, 2026
"They actually got the name right"
I was ready to blame them if the spelling came out wrong, because it’s a personalized necklace and that would’ve been so annoying. But they got my name exactly right, so at least they didn’t mess that up
troy2005
January 09, 2026
"Looked nice at first, but didn’t last"
I thought the necklace was cute when I first got it, like it looked fine right out of the package. But after wearing it a few times, it started looking dull and just not great. The clasp feels kind of cheap too, and the chain is already changing color, which is annoying. I don’t know, maybe it’s okay for very occasional wear, but for me it wasn’t really worth the money...
hello_adrian756
December 31, 2025
"Tarnished after barely wearing it"
I bought a bracelet from Amyo Jewelry i was really excited because it looked so cute when it arrived. But after only a few wears, the color started fading, which is just my luck. I didn’t shower with it, sleep in it, or do anything that should’ve messed it up, so it’s frustrating because I feel like I did everything right and still ended up disappointed. For the price, I really expected it to hold up better.
james-Felix
December 31, 2025
"Pretty, but comfort is hit or miss"
I picked up a bracelet from amyojewelry.com because I really liked the way it looked, but wearing it has been kind of a letdown. It’s cute, sure, but it rubs against my wrist and starts feeling stiff after a few hours. I gave it a couple chances and wore it twice, but both times I ended up taking it off. For me, this one was a miss since I was hoping it’d be something I could wear every day.
Estela_conner83
December 31, 2025
"Return process was more of a hassle than I expected"
I’m not sure if I just caught them at a bad time or what, but my return took longer than I thought it would. The exchange updates were also a little vague, so I kept second-guessing whether it was actually moving along or if I needed to follow up. Maybe it’s not always like this, but I don’t think I’ll be buying again anytime soon.
Jamie.strayer
December 17, 2025
"I’ve been trying to get help..."
I’ve been trying to get help for days, but customer service just keeps ignoring my messages. When I do manage to reach someone, it feels like nobody wants to take ownership of the issue or actually follow up. Really frustrating experience...
chelsea_Mullins79
December 12, 2025
"Felt misled by the shipping time"
I ordered expecting the shipping to be normal, but it ended up taking way longer than I thought. The tracking barely updated for days, so I kept checking and getting the same vague info, which was really frustrating.

Delays happen, I get it, but this definitely had that bait-and-switch feeling where it seems like it’ll arrive in a reasonable time until after you’ve already paid. I wouldn’t order again if I needed something anytime soon.
Genevieve-beasley
December 11, 2025
"Showed up right on time"
Just got my delivery and it arrived exactly when it was supposed to. based on this latest experience, I’m happy with the service. Thanks!
Have a question about AMY O Jewelry?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.